Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Batavia's Original Pizzeria
Welcome to Batavia's Original Pizzeria, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Batavia, New York. Located at 500 E Main St, this charming eatery has quickly become a beloved destination for pizza lovers and comfort food enthusiasts alike.
The atmosphere is inviting, making it a perfect spot for any occasion, whether you're grabbing a quick lunch or enjoying a leisurely dinner with friends and family. The menu is brimming with mouth-watering options that cater to every palate, including their renowned pizza, savory calzones, and delightful salads. Customers rave about the distinct flavors, large portions, and most importantly, the incredible value for money.
- Customer favorites:
- Pizzas: The taco pizza is highly recommended for those looking for something unique and special.
- Calzones: Bursting with flavor, the Italian meat calzone is another standout that keeps patrons coming back.
- Bacon Mac and Cheese: When it comes to comfort food, their Bacon Mac and Cheese is a must-try, earning rave reviews for its creamy richness.
- Service: The friendly staff adds to the warm ambiance, ensuring that every visit feels welcoming and personalized.
- Value: Many reviews highlight the reasonable prices, making it an exceptional choice for families and large groups.
Recent diners have expressed their delight in the quality of food and the generous serving sizes. Miranda Fuller, one satisfied customer, mentioned how she has enjoyed everything from fish fries to wraps during her visits. Others like Tom Fitzgerald have declared it as the best pizza they’ve ever had, proving that this pizzeria does not disappoint.
Whether you're a local or just passing through, Batavia's Original Pizzeria is a must-visit. From their extensive menu to their warm service, it’s an experience that leaves you craving for more. Don’t miss out on trying their buffet option on your next visit, as many customers are eager to explore more of what this delightful pizzeria has to offer!
For inquiries or to place an order, you can reach them at +1 585-343-3303. Enjoy the culinary adventure at Batavia's Original Pizzeria!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ The food was delicious. We went for fish fries on this day but I have ordered pick up many times prior to this day and have enjoyed the salads, wraps, and chicken wings too. This was our first time eating in. The server was kind although she seemed a little bit under the weather. The restaurant was pretty cold and I left my jacket and hat on the whole time. I want to try their buffet So we'll be back to try that but maybe in warmer weather. ”
“ My Fiance and I came from Middleport to Batavia original. She order a small taco pizza they made it special. I had a Italian meat calzone. Both where so delicious . You got try this place out everything is big portions and friendly waitress that attends to her tables. Good job everyone ”
“ Best pizza in my life, no lie! We were on our way to Rochester from Buffalo and live in Florida. Stopped for some pizza and was amazed! Very, very reasonably priced, great service, and unbelievable taste! ”
“ Stopped by while working in the area. The service was very friendlyand slices came out quick. Huge slices! Thick crust! My favorite place to grab lunch while in Batavia. ”
“ I had the Bacon Mac and Cheese tonight. one of the best Mac and cheeses I have had. Great job to the cook on this one. ”
“ Stopped in for lunch today after an appointment in town. Ordered a personal hot honey pizza, a Buffalo chicken calzone, and a half order of hot buffalo wings. The wings were nice and crispy, the pizza crust was crisp and delicious, and they use fresh basil and mozzarella! Everything was delicious and was served quickly. Our server was friendly and attentive. The place was clean and inviting. I would definitely stop back again when in town. ”
“ Ordered pick -up and the customer service was professional. The wings were very dry with minimal sauce and the hawaiian pizza is overly sweet. The batavia original crust is super thick more like a Sicilian slice. The pepperoni pizza was magnificent in flavor and texture! The canoli are pretty good, the inside is more like a pudding consistency. I would definitely give this place another chance and order the NY thin crust and stay away from that sweet sauce UPDATE: Came back and ordered NY crust, it was phenomenal! The layers in the crust was a surprise and the texture was perfectly soft on the inside with a little crunch on the outside. From 3 stars to 5! ”
“ Love the pizza logs here. Can’t get them back home in California. Also, we tried the wings for the first time here. Oh man they were so good. ”